Plasma vs. Laser: How to Choose the Right Cutting Machine

In the modern manufacturing industry, the cutting machine is an important equipment, and when choosing a suitable cutting machine, there are often two options: laser cutting machine and plasma cutting machine. These two cutting techniques each have unique characteristics and areas of application, and it is important to understand their strengths and differences. This article will explore the differences between laser cutters and plasma cutters and provide some guidance to help you choose the right cutter for your needs.

What is a plasma cutting machine?

Compared with laser cutting machines, plasma cutting machines were used earlier, dating back to the 1950s. Plasma cutting machines can easily cut heavy and thick materials.

A plasma cutting machine is a device that uses plasma to cut materials. Plasma is a highly activated gas consisting of ionized gas molecules and free electrons. In a plasma cutting machine, the gas is converted to a plasma state by injecting energy, usually an arc discharge or laser beam, into the gas.

How exactly does it work?

Plasma cutting machines use high-energy plasma streams to cut metal materials by ionizing gas into plasma. Its working steps include gas introduction, arc initiation, plasma generation, directing the plasma flow to the cutting area, and using the plasma flow to heat and cut the material. Precise cutting shapes can be achieved by controlling the intensity, speed and direction of the plasma stream. Steel, stainless steel, aluminum, brass, and copper are common materials cut by plasma torches. Only conductive metals should be used with plasma torches because the workpiece completes the electrical circuit. plasma cutting machines are widely used in manufacturing workshops, automotive repair and restoration, and industrial buildings.

Benefits of plasma cutting machines

Plasma cutting machine has the advantages of high efficiency, precision and multi-material applicability in the field of metal processing and manufacturing, so it is widely used in industrial production.

Advantages over laser cutting machines

Plasma cutting offers the versatility to target different types of metals. An electric arc is used to cut any conductive metal. They can often do a job in a quarter of the time of any other cutting tool.

Advantages over laser cutting:

• less metal loss
• higher quality surface treatment
• reduce maintenance
• Higher plate cutting speed

What is a laser cutting machine?

laser cutting machines utilize high-powered, computer-operated lasers. The core component is an optical fiber containing elements such as erbium, thulium, and dysprosium.

A laser cutting machine achieves cutting by focusing a high-energy laser beam, concentrating the laser energy on a very small area, causing the material to be heated and melted, vaporized or burned.

Laser cutting machines usually use lasers as energy sources, and commonly used laser types include CO2 lasers, fiber lasers, and solid-state lasers. The laser beam generated by the laser is focused by the lens system to form a laser beam with high energy density.

How exactly does it work?

The laser cutting machine generates high-energy laser beams through lasers, which are focused and assisted by gas injection to achieve high-precision cutting of materials. The laser beam interacts with the material, causing the material to be heated and melted, vaporized or burned, and the auxiliary gas blows away the melted material, thereby achieving cutting. Laser cutting machine has the characteristics of precision, high speed, non-contact and small heat-affected area. It is suitable for cutting various materials. Laser cutting is widely used in electronics, medicine, aircraft, transportation and other fields. Due to the laser's ability to perform precise cutting and finishing, it is primarily used for cutting metals such as tungsten, steel, aluminium, brass or nickel. Lasers are also used to cut wood, silicon, ceramics and other non-metals.

Benefits of laser cutting machines

The benefits of laser cutting machines can be summarized as follows: high-precision cutting ability, non-contact cutting to reduce material damage, fast and efficient production speed, suitable for a variety of materials, and automatic control to improve production efficiency.

Advantages over plasma cutting machines：

• high precision
• small heat affected zone
• non-contact cutting
• Multi-material suitability
• Fine Cut Lines
• Automation and Computer Control

The main difference between plasma cutting machine and laser cutting machine

• plasma cutting machines use a mixture of gases and an electric arc while laser cutting machines use a focused beam of light to carry out the cutting process
• Some cutting jobs cannot be handled by a high-definition plasma cutting machine, such as plasma cutting fine saw blades (such jobs require a laser cutting machine).
• Compared with plasma cutting machine, laser cutting machine has higher precision
• The capital investment required for a laser cutting machine is much higher than for a plasma cutting machine
• Fiber laser cutting machines are best for cutting thin sheet metal and can cut all metal types. CO2 laser cutting machines cannot cut copper, brass and aluminum as they are not suitable for reflective surfaces.
• plasma cutting machines are limited to cutting, but can cut all types of metal; laser cutting machines can cut, engrave and weld.
• laser cutting machines can often cut metal faster than plasma cutting machines and use less energy, making them a more environmentally friendly metal cutting option.
• laser cutting machines generally cannot cut materials as thick as plasma cutting machines, and are usually only effective at cutting materials up to 25mm thick. plasma cutting machines can typically cut any type of metal up to a thickness of 80 mm.

How to determine which cutting machine is better for your needs?

• Cutting requirements: First, you need to clarify your cutting requirements, including material type, cutting thickness, cutting shape and precision requirements, etc. If you need to cut thicker metal materials or require higher precision, a laser cutting machine may be a better fit. However, if you mainly cut thicker metal materials and do not require high precision, a plasma cutting machine may be more suitable.

• Material Type: Consider the type of material you need to cut. laser cutting machines are suitable for a wide variety of materials, including metal, plastic, wood, and more. The plasma cutting machine is mainly used for cutting metal materials.

• Cost Factors: Consider equipment costs, operating costs, and maintenance costs. laser cutting machines generally have higher equipment costs but lower operating costs in some areas such as tool consumption and maintenance. plasma cutting machines are relatively low in equipment cost, but have high operating costs in areas such as gas consumption and tool maintenance.

• Productivity and Speed: Consider your production needs and time constraints. Laser cutting machines usually have high cutting speed and production efficiency, suitable for mass production. Although the cutting speed of the plasma cutting machine is slower, it still has a better cutting effect for thicker metal materials.

Conclusion:

Both types of cutting machines have their own advantages, and factors such as cutting requirements, material type, cost and production efficiency need to be considered comprehensively. If you want to know more about related knowledge, please contact Durmark, we will provide you with the most effective help.

Get A Quote Now!